Movie Review: Conclave
- Dave Carey
- Jan 7
- 3 min read
Updated: Jan 24

Conclave is an exquisite, gripping exploration of faith, power, and humanity’s inherent flaws. Directed with masterful precision, the film delves into the intense and deeply secretive process of selecting a new pope, immersing viewers in an environment both sacred and political. Its deliberate pacing, outstanding performances, and remarkable production design come together to create an experience that is both thought-provoking and emotionally resonant.
The ensemble cast of Conclave delivers performances that feel authentic, layered, and deeply human. The actors rise to the challenge of portraying characters constrained by their faith but driven by ambition, loyalty, and personal beliefs. Each priest, cardinal, and papal candidate is brought to life with nuance, showcasing a range of emotions that include hope, fear, and conflict. The standout performances are subtle yet commanding, with the actors embracing the gravity of the story without veering into melodrama. Their chemistry ensures that every dialogue feels natural, every confrontation gripping, and every alliance believable.
The direction of Conclave is a triumph in setting and maintaining tone. The filmmaker demonstrates a keen understanding of the gravity of the subject matter, balancing reverence for the Catholic Church’s rituals with an unflinching examination of its internal politics. The slow, deliberate pacing mirrors the real-life process of electing a pope, giving audiences the space to absorb the weight of each decision, vote, and negotiation. The storytelling allows the intricate web of alliances, rivalries, and factions to unfold naturally, drawing viewers deeper into the story with every passing scene.
The production design and costumes in Conclave are breathtaking, transforming the film into a visual feast. The sets, from the grandeur of the Sistine Chapel to the austere yet elegant private quarters of the cardinals, are meticulously crafted to reflect the sacred yet political nature of the conclave. The costumes are equally stunning, with the cardinals’ red robes and the papal vestments serving as symbols of power, tradition, and faith. Together, the sets and costumes create an atmosphere that feels both timeless and tangible, immersing viewers in the world of the Vatican with stunning authenticity.
The deliberate pacing of Conclave is one of its greatest strengths. By allowing the story to unfold gradually, the film gives the audience a profound sense of the time, effort, and emotional toll involved in electing a new pope. The drawn-out process emphasizes the stakes for the Church and the individual cardinals, highlighting the constant negotiation, in-fighting, and factionalism within the priesthood. It also sheds light on the weight of tradition and the clash between progressivism and conservatism within the Church.
The film does an exceptional job of humanizing the cardinals, showing that they are not merely representatives of the divine but flawed individuals grappling with their faith, ambitions, and doubts. This approach makes the story accessible and relatable, even for those who may not be familiar with Catholicism.
Conclave has sparked a wide range of reactions, from critical acclaim to controversy. Political pundits and certain factions within the Catholic community have taken unnecessary offense to the film, accusing it of sensationalism or misrepresentation. However, these criticisms often stem from a lack of understanding of the papal election process. The irony is that those truly knowledgeable about the conclave, who could accurately assess the film’s authenticity, would never speak publicly about such a sacred and secretive event.
Critics with a deeper appreciation for the art of storytelling have praised the film for its thoughtful approach, lauding it as a rare and courageous exploration of a hidden world. They have highlighted the accuracy of the film’s depiction of political maneuvering within the Church and its unflinching portrayal of the humanity of its leaders.
Conclave is a masterful achievement, blending stellar performances, meticulous direction, and stunning production design to create a film that is as beautiful as it is compelling. It offers a rare glimpse into one of the world’s most secretive and sacred rituals, shedding light on the humanity and politics at the heart of the Catholic Church. While it may face criticism from those unwilling to engage with its themes, Conclave stands as a bold, thoughtful, and unforgettable piece of cinema. This is a film that demands to be seen, discussed, and appreciated for its artistry and insight. - Dave Carey
Proofread and edited using AI Tools